Daring Bakers Challenge :: March 2010 : Lemon Tian

If this had been a mid-term exam for Daring Bakers 101, I would have failed miserably. The 2010 March Daring Baker’s challenge was hosted by Jennifer of Chocolate Shavings. She chose Orange Tian as the challenge for this month, a dessert based on a recipe from Alain Ducasse’s Cooking School in Paris. I should have known things would go awry when I first saw the name for what I’m sure is normally a delectable dessert. Ti-a… what???

Though I’d never heard of a Tian before, I naively went into this challenge with the over-confidence of a two-year old. First mistake. Not only did I leave a fairly time consuming recipe to the last minute, but I chose to use an alternate option for the recipe as well. I am in no way a fan of oranges in my desserts. In fact, I’m not much of an orange person in general. To me, oranges are for half-time, to be eaten fresh, torn right from the skin, juices dripping down your chin as you replenish yourself for the rest of the big game. I’ve never understood the wide-spread devotion to the pairing of say, chocolate and orange, such as with Terry’s Chocolate Orange Balls (most popular around Christmas). So, I chose to use lemons instead…. second mistake. Lemons are sour. Duh. Very sour. The failures carried on from there… not enough sugar to temper the tartness of the lemons… a pate sablee that was far too crumbly and required much more than the recommended “couple drops of water” (it was more like 1/2 a cup by the time I was done)… a caramel that I not only burnt the first batch of, but had my spatula partially melt into as well… and so on and so forth.

Despite all of that, I still managed to make the end result look a bit pretty; and ignoring the sour zing that seemed to go straight to the back of my eyeballs with every bite, this lemon tian actually tasted a little like lemon meringue pie. Now that I can deal with!

I won’t be posting the recipe for this one, but for the linguistically thorough, here’s a quick run-down of what a Tian is all about: http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-a-tian.htm Enjoy!

  • http://www.littleredsaid.blogspot.com debbie

    I'm excited to see someone who tried the lemon version! I wondered if it would taste like lemon meringue pie! Good for you…..I couldn't wrap my head around how to go about sweetening the lemons on top so I chickened out and went with the plain orange. I could have done without the caramel….but I may have made it too dark….will have to try it again sometime:)

  • Brown Sugar

    Thank you! I think if I were to try it again, prior to covering the lemon segments with the caramel I would coat them with a dusting of sugar and let them sit for a while. Half an hour at least. Let me know how it turns out if you try it again. :-)

  • http://audaxartifex.blogspot.com/ Audax Artifex

    Wow I'm very impressed with your determination on this challenge. The pate sablee looks to Ok to me and yes sometimes it does take a lot more water than stated in the recipe. At least the ;pictures look great and I think this challenge is just passed since you know what to do next time. Cheers from Audax in Sydney Australia.

  • http://themorethanoccasionalbaker.blogspot.com/ bakingaddict

    Certainly looks delicious from here. I love a great lemon zing :)

  • Brown Sugar

    Thank you!

  • Brown Sugar

    Thanks Audax! You’re always so faithfully positive – I love it! Cheers!